The Compliance Pitfalls That Kill CPG Launches (And How to Dodge Them)

Most new food and beverage founders don’t come from regulatory backgrounds—and it shows.

You can build a gorgeous brand, land retail interest, and still get derailed by a minor compliance issue. Not because you’re sloppy. Because the rules are murky, inconsistent, and buried in PDFs you’ve never seen.

Let’s break down the most common pitfalls—and how to avoid them.

1. You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know

Here’s how it usually plays out:

You apply for retail and get accepted… only to find out your label needs French.
You say “non-GMO” on your packaging… without the cert to back it up.
You list an NPN product in Canada… but miss the fine print about shelf stability or health claims.

In retail, compliance isn’t just about legality—it’s about trust. And a single oversight can delay your launch, trigger a recall, or cost you thousands.

Why this happens:

Compliance requirements are scattered across government sites, retailer manuals, and third-party certifiers.
Standards change without notice — what was fine last year may fail this year’s review.
Founders often focus on product development and sales, leaving compliance until “later” — which is usually too late.

What to do right now:

Collect retailer requirements early — Even if you’re 6–12 months from applying, download supplier manuals from your target retailers. Look for sections on packaging, labelling, and product claims.
Run a mock compliance review — Have an industry-savvy consultant or regulatory specialist review your current label and product specs as if they were a retailer’s compliance team.
Audit your claims — Make a spreadsheet of every marketing claim on your packaging (e.g., “gluten-free,” “sustainably sourced”) and add the source of verification for each (certificate, lab test, or legal exemption).
Check cross-border differences — If you plan to sell in both the U.S. and Canada, verify bilingual rules, nutrition panel formats, and claim thresholds now — not after your first PO.
Document everything — Keep digital copies of certs, approvals, and correspondence with regulators. Retailers may ask for proof on short notice.

Don’t wait for the buyer to catch your mistake.
goCPG’s free AI mentor can run a packaging or compliance check in seconds—based on your product type, market, and retailer.

2. Canada and the U.S. Are Not the Same Market

You might assume your U.S. label is fine for Canada—or vice versa.

Wrong. Even between two neighbouring countries, retail requirements differ in ways that can catch even experienced brands off guard.

Key Differences at a Glance

Requirement	Canada	U.S.
Bilingual Labels	Mandatory (English & French on most consumer products)	Not required; English only is standard
Nutrition Facts Panel	Specific format with black-and-white box; bilingual	Different FDA-regulated format; English only
Ingredient Lists	Descending order by weight, bilingual	Descending order by weight, English
Claims (e.g., “Low Sugar”)	Must meet Health Canada’s strict thresholds	Must meet FDA thresholds, which can differ significantly
Certifications	Canada Organic, Gluten-Free Certified (per Canadian standards)	USDA Organic, Gluten-Free Certified (per U.S. standards)
Barcodes	GS1 Canada preferred; UPC-A format	GS1 U.S. preferred; UPC-A format

Launching cross-border?
goCPG can tell you what needs to change, what’s optional, and where to find certified help.

3. Certs Aren’t Just a Flex—They’re a Filter

Some buyers require certifications. Others just use them to sort applicants. Either way, certifications can act as a fast-track into certain stores or channels, especially when a retailer’s category review process is crowded.

Below is a breakdown of common certifications you’ll see in food and beverage CPG—and why they matter.

Certification	What It Means	Why It’s Relevant
Non-GMO Project Verified	Indicates that the product has been tested and meets strict standards to avoid genetically modified organisms (GMOs).	Many natural and specialty retailers prefer or require this for products marketed as clean-label or natural. Builds trust with health-conscious shoppers.
USDA Organic / Canada Organic	Ensures products meet national organic standards, including sourcing, production, and handling without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers.	Essential for entry into the organic set in grocery chains. Required for products marketed as “organic” in the U.S. or Canada.
Gluten-Free Certified	Confirms that a product contains less than the allowable limit of gluten (usually under 20 ppm) and has been tested by a recognized certifying body.	Critical for brands targeting consumers with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity. Often a requirement for placement in allergen-friendly aisles.
Kosher	Signifies the product complies with Jewish dietary laws, verified by an accredited kosher certifying agency.	Expands your market reach to observant Jewish consumers and retailers that cater to diverse dietary needs.
Halal	Indicates compliance with Islamic dietary laws, verified by a recognized halal certification authority.	Vital for accessing Muslim-majority markets and regions, as well as halal-focused retail programs.
Health Canada NPN	A Natural Product Number is required for supplements, vitamins, and certain functional foods sold in Canada. Shows compliance with safety, efficacy, and quality standards.	Without it, you cannot legally sell certain natural health products in Canada. Mandatory for functional or fortified products making health claims.
Allergen Statements	Clear, standardized labelling of common allergens present in your product, such as peanuts, dairy, soy, or mustard.	Required by law in both the U.S. and Canada. Helps consumers make safe purchasing decisions and builds brand credibility.
Traceability / Clean-Label Indicators	Demonstrates the ability to trace ingredients back through the supply chain and commitment to transparency in sourcing.	Increasingly demanded by large retailers to manage risk and respond to recalls quickly. Also a selling point for ethically-minded shoppers.
SQF / GFSI Audits for Co-Packers	Safe Quality Food (SQF) and Global Food Safety Initiative (GFSI) certifications confirm adherence to rigorous food safety and quality standards.	Many national retailers require that your manufacturing partner hold one of these certifications before they’ll list your product.

How to Acquire These Certifications

The process varies by certification, but generally involves:

Understanding the standard: Download the full requirements from the certifying body (e.g., USDA, Non-GMO Project) and make sure your ingredients, sourcing, and processes align.
Choosing an accredited certifier: Many certifications require you to work with an approved third-party auditor. The certifying body will usually provide a list — here are some well-known accredited certifiers:

Quality Assurance International (QAI) – Organic certification for U.S., Canada, and international markets.
California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF) – One of the largest organic certifiers in North America.
Oregon Tilth – Organic certification and sustainable agriculture advocacy.
SCS Global Services – Certifies Non-GMO Project Verified, organic, and sustainability claims.
Non-GMO Project – The primary verification body for non-GMO claims in North America.
Gluten-Free Certification Organization (GFCO) – Leading gluten-free certification for CPG products.
OK Kosher – Global kosher certification provider.
Islamic Food and Nutrition Council of America (IFANCA) – Widely recognized Halal certification body.
Safe Quality Food Institute (SQFI) – Administers SQF certification under the GFSI framework.

Preparing documentation: Be ready to provide sourcing records, supplier certifications, product formulations, and process descriptions.
On-site audits or inspections: Some certifications, like SQF or organic, require facility visits to verify compliance.
Paying fees: Certification costs can range from a few hundred dollars (for basic label claims) to several thousand per year for more complex certifications with annual audits.

What You Should Be Thinking About

Not every certification is worth the investment for every brand. Before you commit, ask yourself:

Does my target retailer require it? If a key buyer won’t even review your product without a certain cert, that’s a priority.
Does my audience value it? Organic certification means more to a Whole Foods shopper than to a price-first club store customer.
Can I meet the standard consistently? A single slip in ingredient sourcing can void your certification — and hurt trust.
Do I have the budget? Factor in not just the initial cost but ongoing renewal and compliance costs.
Is this part of my brand positioning? Certifications can help justify premium pricing if they’re meaningful to your customer base.

You don’t need all of them—but you do need to know which ones matter for your category and sales channels.

Unsure what your channel expects? Ask goCPG’s AI mentor. It’ll scan your category and make a recommendation, saving you from costly missteps.

4. Compliance Is a Moving Target

What passed last year may not work this year — and the changes don’t always come with big announcements.

Retailers update requirements constantly: A regional grocery chain might suddenly mandate front-of-pack sugar disclosure icons for all beverages, even if you’ve been selling there for years.
Ingredient bans are growing: In 2023, several U.S. states moved to restrict titanium dioxide in confections. Brands that relied on it for color had to reformulate mid-contract.
New sustainability rules: Canadian retailers like Loblaw and Sobeys are expanding plastic packaging phase-outs ahead of federal timelines, forcing suppliers to switch to recyclable or compostable materials sooner.
Labeling changes: In 2024, Health Canada tightened rules around “low sugar” claims — brands using the claim without meeting the new threshold had to reprint or cover labels before shipping.
Traceability requirements: Walmart’s produce suppliers must now integrate into blockchain-based traceability systems; similar expectations are trickling into packaged CPG categories.
Category-specific shifts: Some natural retailers have started refusing products containing certain seed oils, artificial sweeteners, or PFAS-treated packaging, even though they remain legal federally.

The worst part? These updates aren’t centralized. You’ll find them scattered across supplier manuals, Excel downloads, sales rep emails, or even buried in contract renewals.

The goCPG AI mentor is trained on the latest known retail data and founder FAQs. If it doesn’t know—it’ll point you to someone who does.

Final Thoughts

Compliance isn’t glamorous. It doesn’t win you awards or viral traction. But get it wrong, and it can quietly kill your brand before it ever gets a fair shot. The solution?

Don’t wing it.
Don’t wait until the buyer points it out.
Use the free tools at your disposal—like goCPG’s AI expert—and go to market with confidence.

Because when you look buttoned-up, retailers take you seriously.
And when they trust you, they’re a lot more likely to bet on you.

Articles